This article is stated as at 22 November 2026. ICAEW guidance and the Companies Act 2006 may be amended. Take advice on your own circumstances before acting.
Every compiled accounts file has two readers: the partner who signs it now, and the person who opens it a year later without having been in the room. A sound accounts preparation file review leaves a trail that second reader can follow. It shows who prepared the accounts, who reviewed them and when, which points were raised and how each was resolved, and that all of this happened before the directors approved the accounts and a director signed the balance sheet under section 414 of the Companies Act 2006. That applies to every ICAEW firm that prepares statutory accounts, whether or not it also audits.
Does ISQM (UK) 1 apply to accounts preparation work?
The FRC’s quality management standard is ISQM (UK) 1, and its full title covers firms that perform audits or reviews of financial statements, or other assurance or related services engagements. It took effect on 15 December 2022, by which date firms in scope had to have designed and implemented their system of quality management, and the first annual evaluation of that system was due by 15 December 2023. The current edition is marked “Issued July 2021 (Updated September 2025)”.
A compilation falls outside it. The UK sentence in paragraph 5 of the standard limits its scope to engagements carried out under performance standards issued by the FRC, such as audits under ISAs (UK), and accounts preparation is not one of them. ICAEW’s March 2023 Q&A applies the same paragraph to charity independent examinations, placing them outside scope while saying the firm should still consider how it manages the quality of that work. Accounts preparation sits outside for the same reason, and the same advice on managing its quality applies. Be aware too that ICAEW’s own accounts preparation page still refers to ISQC 1 and AAF 2/10, so it has not caught up with either the current standard or the current compilation guidance.
In practice the scope question matters less than it first appears, because the Code of Ethics duty of professional competence and due care applies to every engagement, and Practice Assurance applies to the firm regardless. For a firm that also audits, ICAEW’s suggestion that it may be simplest to apply the ISQM framework across all engagements is sensible: two review standards in one office tend to settle at the weaker of the two. Our guide to quality management for accounts preparation sets out how that framework maps onto compiled work.
What evidence should an accounts preparation file review show?
ICAEW describes a compilation as arranging the client’s data and information into financial statements. The procedures do not involve verifying that data, no conclusion is expressed, and independence is not a requirement. Even so, the accounts leave the practice with an accountant’s report bearing the firm’s name, so the file has to show that someone competent checked them. Initials on a cover sheet do not do that on their own, because a later reader needs to see what was reviewed, by whom, when, and how each point was settled.
| Item on file | What it should show |
|---|---|
| Engagement letter | In place before work began, with the basis of fees and complaints information |
| Preparer sign off | Name, date and what the preparer completed |
| Reviewer sign off | Name, date and the scope of the review (statements, notes, disclosures) |
| Review notes | Each point raised, the response, who cleared it and when |
| Significant matters | The conclusion on matters such as going concern or an omitted disclosure, with the reasoning |
| Director approval | Evidence the board approved the accounts and a director signed the balance sheet |
| Accountant’s report | Current ICAEW wording, signed once the review was complete |
The accountant’s report should follow TECH 07/16 AAF, ICAEW’s release on compilation reports for incorporated entities, dated 28 March 2016. Its companion, TECH 08/16 AAF, dated 29 March 2016, covers unincorporated entities and replaced AUDIT 03/10. The full text of both is for members only. If any report template in your system dates from the AAF 2/10 era, retire it.
For an acquirer assessing a target’s files in due diligence, the table works as a sampling checklist. A complete file does not prove the work was good, but gaps across several rows tell you more about a firm’s habits than its quality manual will.
How should review notes be raised and cleared?
Review notes are the part of the file that proves review took place, and they are the part most often lost. Two habits cause most of the damage. One is deleting or overwriting notes once they are cleared, so the final file shows tidy accounts with no history of the matters raised. The other is clearing a point with “done” or “agreed”, which tells a reader that something happened without telling them what was decided.
Take a hypothetical owner managed company with net liabilities at the year end, where the manager raises going concern. A note cleared “done” records nothing useful. A note cleared “Director has confirmed in writing that they will not seek repayment of their loan account; letter on file; going concern note updated; partner agreed the basis of preparation” records the evidence and where it sits, the change to the accounts and who made the judgement. It costs one sentence and answers the questions any later reviewer will ask.
A workable standard for most practices:
- Keep every note on the final file, with the date it was cleared and the initials of whoever cleared it.
- Short clearances are fine for mechanical points such as a casting error or a comparative not rolled forward.
- Anything involving judgement goes to the partner, and their conclusion is written down in a sentence or two.
The points that come up repeatedly are worth knowing in advance; our note on common errors at manager review lists those we see most often on small company accounts.
Review has to finish before the directors sign
The legal responsibility for the accounts sits with the directors. Section 393(1) says they must not approve accounts unless satisfied that they give a true and fair view. Section 414 requires the board to approve the accounts and a director to sign the balance sheet on its behalf, with a prominent statement above the signature where the accounts are prepared under the small companies regime (or a statement that they are prepared under the micro entity provisions). A director who knew the accounts did not comply with the Act, or was reckless as to whether they did, and failed to take reasonable steps to secure compliance or prevent approval commits an offence punishable by a fine. Section 386 places the duty to keep adequate accounting records on the company, too.
So the file’s job is to show that the accounts the practice put in front of the directors had already been reviewed. A reviewer’s sign off dated after the director’s signature on the balance sheet shows the opposite: whatever review took place did not shape the accounts that were approved. Make the date check part of the partner’s final sign off, and treat any open review note as a reason not to send the accounts for approval yet.
Cold file reviews and Practice Assurance
ICAEW’s cold file helpsheet notes that ISQM 1 calls a cold file review a review of a completed engagement, and that the engagement team and the engagement quality reviewer may not carry it out. The helpsheet’s checklist is built for audits, so a firm reviewing compiled files will need to adapt it. It also recommends sharing the results and agreed actions with those involved in the work, and suggests root cause analysis as a way to decide what to do next. In a sole practice or a small firm where everyone works on everything, keeping the reviewer separate from the work usually means looking outside the firm. Our comparison of cold file and hot review covers when each earns its place.
Practice Assurance has separate standards for smaller and larger firms. ICAEW’s compliance review helpsheet offers a checklist for reviewing the firm’s procedures against those standards, and says there is no requirement under the Practice Assurance Regulations or Standards to carry one out, though firms often find it useful. The 2026 monitoring report lists engagement letters and the basis of fees and complaints among the top areas of non compliance, alongside annual returns, anti money laundering, clients’ money and professional indemnity insurance. It does not single out the quality of accounts preparation files. ICAEW’s November 2026 reminder on fees and complaints is blunt: “Make sure complaints information is provided before work begins.” Our note on what Practice Assurance looks for goes through the file in more detail.
For firms within ISQM (UK) 1, ICAEW’s podcast on ISQM described monitoring and remediation as the driving force of the system, and said that “leadership should continue to be highly involved in the process”. ICAEW’s February 2026 webinar, “ISQM (UK) 1: Making file reviews matter”, ties file review to the annual evaluation. If your evaluation is coming up, sample a handful of compiled files against the table above before it, so that what you find can go into it.
When software or AI has reviewed the accounts
A review tool changes what the file needs to show, though it leaves the responsibility where it was. The common gap is a file where the tool flagged points but nothing records what it covered, which points it raised, or what anyone did about them. A reader then cannot tell whether a person considered each point or simply accepted the output.
The file should record the scope of the tool’s review, each point it raised, who considered it and what they concluded, and the partner’s own sign off on the accounts. Our page on the audit trail for AI review sets out what each review point should show. We build Infinite Accountant on that footing: it raises review points for a person to consider, and clearing them and signing off stays with the reviewer and the partner. Our guide to signing off accounts reviewed with AI covers the professional responsibility in full.
Key dates
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| 28 March 2016 | TECH 07/16 AAF on compilation reports for incorporated entities issued |
| 29 March 2016 | TECH 08/16 AAF for unincorporated entities issued, replacing AUDIT 03/10 |
| 15 December 2022 | ISQM (UK) 1 effective; systems of quality management in place for firms in scope |
| 15 December 2023 | First annual evaluation of the system of quality management due |
| 25 September 2025 | Current edition of ISQM (UK) 1 published |
| 26 February 2026 | ICAEW webinar “ISQM (UK) 1: Making file reviews matter” broadcast |
| 1 July 2026 | New edition of the ICAEW Code of Ethics in force |
Questions practices ask
Does every set of compiled accounts need to be signed off by a partner?
Not necessarily. The accounts themselves are approved by the board and signed by a director under section 414 of the Companies Act 2006. Who signs off the review inside the practice is for the firm's own procedures, which should say which files need partner review, such as those with going concern doubts or significant judgements. The file should then show that the policy was followed on that engagement.
Who can carry out a cold file review in a sole practice?
ICAEW's cold file helpsheet notes that under ISQM 1 the engagement team and the engagement quality reviewer may not carry out the review of a completed engagement. In a sole practice the principal has usually worked on every file, so keeping the reviewer separate from the work generally means asking someone from outside the firm to look at a sample of files and agreeing actions with them.
Do we have to carry out a Practice Assurance compliance review?
ICAEW's helpsheet says there is no requirement under the Practice Assurance Regulations or Standards to carry out a compliance review, although firms often find it useful. It provides a checklist for a systematic review of the firm's procedures against the standards, with separate standards for smaller and larger firms. The checklist itself is available to ICAEW members only.
Do we need to be independent of a client to prepare their accounts?
No. ICAEW's accounts preparation guidance states that independence is not a requirement for compilation engagements, because the accountant arranges the client's information into financial statements without verifying it and expresses no conclusion on them. The wider ethical duties, including professional competence and due care, still apply, and the file should still show that the accounts were reviewed before the directors approved them.
Sources
- ISQM (UK) 1 Quality Management for Firms that Perform Audits or Reviews of Financial Statements, or Other Assurance or Related Services Engagements
- Companies Act 2006, section 414 Approval and signing of accounts
- Companies Act 2006, section 393 Accounts to give true and fair view
- Companies Act 2006, section 386 Duty to keep accounting records
- Audit and Assurance Technical Releases (TECH 07/16 AAF, TECH 08/16 AAF)
- Accounts preparation/Compilation
- Q&A: March 2023
- ISQM, preparing and filing accounts, and public practice (podcast transcript)
- Cold file audit compliance review
- ISQM: Making file reviews matter
- Practice assurance compliance review
- Practice Assurance resources
- Practice Assurance monitoring report
- Three common compliance issues and how to avoid them
- Get ready for 2026 update to ICAEW Code of Ethics