§ InsightsNo. 108

Comparatives and prior period adjustments: a reviewer’s checks

How a reviewer checks comparatives, tells a policy change from a prior period error, and tests a restatement against FRS 102 Section 10 and 1AC.8.

A reviewer comparing last year's accounts with this year's draft to check comparatives and prior period adjustments under FRS 102

Comparatives and prior period adjustments are where a reviewer finds out whether this year’s accounts follow from last year’s. This article is for partners and managers who review small company accounts prepared under FRS 102 Section 1A or FRS 105, and it sets out the checks on comparatives, the difference between a change of policy and a prior period error, what a restatement must disclose, and where the Companies Act wording in paragraph 1AC.8 comes in. It goes further into one part of our checklist for reviewing small company accounts.

What the standards require of comparatives

FRS 102 paragraph 3.14 says that, except when the standard permits or requires otherwise, an entity shall present comparative information in respect of the preceding period for all amounts presented in the current period’s financial statements. It adds that comparative information for narrative and descriptive information must be included when it is relevant to an understanding of the current period’s financial statements. Paragraph 1A.10 applies paragraph 3.14 to a small entity. For a micro-entity, FRS 105 paragraph 3.7 says the same, and paragraph 3.10 explains that a complete set of financial statements means at least two of each required statement and related notes.

The Companies Act requirements are carried into Section 1A through Appendix C. Three paragraphs matter for comparatives.

  • 1AC.7: where the presentation of the statement of financial position or income statement changes, particulars of the change must be given in a note to the financial statements in which the new presentation is first used, and the reasons explained.
  • 1AC.8: where the corresponding amount for the preceding period is not comparable with the amount shown for the item in the current period, and the corresponding amount is adjusted, the particulars of the non-comparability and of any adjustment must be disclosed in a note.
  • 1AC.9: where any amount relating to a preceding reporting period is included in any item in the income statement, the effect must be stated.

The commentary to 1AC.8 says it is likely to be relevant where there has either been a change in accounting policy or the correction of a material prior period error, and refers to paragraphs 10.13, 10.14 and 10.23 for similar requirements.

Agreeing comparatives to last year

The first check is mechanical. Take the signed prior-year accounts, not the prior-year trial balance, and agree every comparative on every statement and note. A difference is acceptable only where it has an explanation, and the explanation is on file and in the note.

  1. Agree each comparative on the balance sheet and income statement to the signed accounts, line by line.
  2. Where a line differs, find the reason: a reclassification, a change of policy, or a correction of an error. Each has a different note.
  3. Agree the opening position, so that last year’s closing reserves are this year’s opening reserves, unless a restatement says otherwise and the note explains it.
  4. Check that every note which has a figure for the current year also has one for the prior year, unless the standard allows otherwise.
  5. Read the narrative comparatives. Paragraph 3.14 asks for them where they help understanding of the current period.

A period that is longer or shorter than a year needs its own disclosures. Paragraph 3.10 requires the entity to disclose that fact and the reason for using a longer or shorter period, and the comparatives are then not for a like period, which the note must make clear.

Policy change, estimate or error

The same adjustment can arise from three different causes, and the treatment depends on which it is. The reviewer’s first question for any adjustment that touches the opening position is therefore why it is there.

A change in accounting policy

Paragraph 10.11(d) requires an entity to account for all other changes in accounting policy, those not covered by transitional provisions, retrospectively. Paragraph 10.12 says the new policy is applied to comparative information for prior periods to the earliest date for which it is practicable, as if it had always been applied. Where it is impracticable to determine the individual-period effects, the new policy is applied to the carrying amounts of assets and liabilities at the beginning of the earliest period for which retrospective application is practicable, with a corresponding adjustment to the opening balance of each affected component of equity. Where a change results from an amendment to FRS 102, paragraph 10.11(a) says to follow the transitional provisions in that amendment. Our guide to the FRS 102 changes from 2026 covers what those amendments mean for a reviewer.

A prior period error

Paragraph 10.19 defines prior period errors as omissions from, and misstatements in, financial statements for one or more prior periods arising from a failure to use, or misuse of, reliable information that was available when those financial statements were authorised for issue and could reasonably be expected to have been obtained and taken into account. Paragraph 10.20 says such errors include the effects of mathematical mistakes, mistakes in applying accounting policies, oversights or misinterpretations of facts, and fraud.

The test is what was available and reasonably obtainable when the earlier accounts were approved. An adjustment made this year because information has since arrived is not necessarily an error. The reviewer asks what was known at the prior approval date, and keeps the answer on file.

A change in estimate

Paragraph 10.18 requires the nature of a change in an accounting estimate to be disclosed. The reviewer’s concern is that a correction of an error is not described as a change in estimate to avoid restating the comparatives.

Restating a prior period error

Paragraph 10.21 requires, to the extent practicable, a material prior period error to be corrected retrospectively in the first financial statements authorised for issue after its discovery, by restating the comparative amounts for the prior periods presented in which the error occurred, or, if the error occurred before the earliest prior period presented, by restating the opening balances of assets, liabilities and equity for the earliest prior period presented. Where it is impracticable to determine the period-specific effects, paragraph 10.22 requires the opening balances for the earliest period for which restatement is practicable to be restated, which may be the current period.

Paragraph 10.23 lists what must be disclosed about material prior period errors.

  • The nature of the prior period error.
  • For each prior period presented, to the extent practicable, the amount of the correction for each financial statement line item affected.
  • To the extent practicable, the amount of the correction at the beginning of the earliest prior period presented.
  • An explanation if it is impracticable to determine those amounts.

The disclosures need not be repeated in later periods. For a small entity, the Appendix C requirement is 1AC.8, which refers to paragraph 10.23 as addressing similar requirements. Paragraph 1A.17 says disclosure requirements in Sections 8 to 35 may still be needed where relevant to material transactions, other events or conditions, in order to give a true and fair view. We would give the 10.23 disclosures where the error is material.

The word material carries the weight here, and it is a judgement for the partner. The review file should say why the error was treated as material or not, and what the alternative treatment would have been.

A worked example

A hypothetical example. A small company’s accounts for the year ended 31 March 2026 were signed with creditors of £48,000. In preparing the year ended 31 March 2027 accounts, the preparer finds that an invoice for £12,000 of professional fees relating to the earlier year was never accrued. Ignoring tax, the figures are as follows.

Item for year ended 31 March 2026As signedRestated
Creditors£48,000£60,000
Profit for the year£35,000£23,000
Closing reserves£120,000£108,000

If the board treats the error as material, paragraph 10.21(a) calls for the comparative amounts to be restated, because the error occurred in a period presented. The restated comparatives then differ from the signed accounts, so 1AC.8 requires a note giving the particulars of the non-comparability and of the adjustment. Paragraph 10.23 supplies the content: the nature of the error, and the correction for each line affected, here creditors, professional fees, profit and reserves. The opening reserves for the current year are £108,000, which the reviewer agrees to the restated closing position, so the signed £120,000 is no longer the comparison.

Posting the £12,000 as an expense in the current year without a restatement would overstate this year’s cost and understate last year’s, and would leave the comparatives agreeing to the signed accounts. The note and the numbers would then both be wrong, though the accounts would cast and the comparatives would agree, which is why the review reads the adjustment itself as well as the agreement.

FRS 105 accounts

The structure is the same, with different paragraph numbers. FRS 105 paragraph 8.16 requires a material prior period error to be corrected retrospectively in the first financial statements authorised for issue after its discovery, by restating the comparative amounts or, if the error is older, the opening balances for the earliest prior period presented. Paragraph 8.17 covers the impracticable case. Paragraph 6B.7 is the micro-entity equivalent of 1AC.8: where the corresponding amount for the preceding period is not comparable with the current amount, the former amount may be adjusted, and particulars of the adjustment and the reasons must be given in a note.

Paragraph 5.4 adds that corrections of material errors and changes in accounting policies are presented as retrospective adjustments of prior periods rather than as part of profit or loss in the period in which they arise. A correction that runs through this year’s income statement is therefore a presentation point to challenge. Our guide to file review and evidence of review covers how the challenge and the answer are kept on file.

Questions practices ask

Do comparatives have to agree to last year’s signed accounts?

Yes, unless they have been adjusted. Where the corresponding amount is adjusted because it is not comparable, paragraph 1AC.8 requires a note giving the particulars of the non-comparability and the adjustment.

When is a prior period error restated?

When it is material and restatement is practicable. Paragraph 10.21 requires it in the first financial statements authorised for issue after the error is discovered.

What if the effect on each prior period cannot be worked out?

Paragraph 10.22 requires the opening balances for the earliest period for which restatement is practicable to be restated, and paragraph 10.23(d) requires an explanation of why the amounts cannot be determined.

Is a change of accounting policy treated in the same way?

Mostly. Paragraphs 10.11 and 10.12 apply the new policy retrospectively unless a transitional provision says otherwise, and paragraphs 10.13 and 10.14 set the disclosures, which a small entity gives where they are relevant to a true and fair view (paragraph 1A.17).

Do micro-entities restate comparatives?

Yes, under FRS 105 paragraphs 8.16 and 8.17, with the note required by paragraph 6B.7.

Sources