§ InsightsNo. 164

FRS 102 cumulative catch up or full restatement for revenue?

Revised Section 23 offers two transition routes for revenue. How each works, which contracts it reaches and what the notes must show.

Two accountants comparing this year's accounts with last year's file to apply the FRS 102 cumulative catch-up for revenue

This article is stated as at 21 November 2026. The FRC amendments are in force, but the corporation tax treatment of revenue transition adjustments rests on professional commentary rather than HMRC guidance specific to the change, and the position of Section 1A transition disclosures is a matter of judgement. Take advice on your own circumstances before acting.

The FRS 102 cumulative catch up lets a client move to the revised Section 23 without restating last year’s revenue. For the first period beginning on or after 1 January 2026, paragraph 1.61 lets an entity either take the cumulative effect of the new revenue rules to opening retained earnings at the date of initial application, without restating comparatives, or restate in full under paragraph 10.12. For a 31 December 2026 year end, that date is 1 January 2026. Every FRS 102 reporter with contracts with customers has to make the choice, and that includes Section 1A small companies.

How do the two revenue transition routes work?

Paragraph 1.40(a) fixes the date of initial application as the start of the period in which the amendments are first applied, and paragraph 1.61 of the FRC’s amendments gives the two routes.

The FRC’s Factsheet 9 calls the paragraph 1.61(a) route the “modified retrospective approach”, and that label helps on a review file. The phrase “cumulative catch up basis” also appears in the revised Section 23 itself, in paragraph 23.16(b), where it describes how a contract modification that is not distinct is recognised as an adjustment to revenue at the date of the modification. That paragraph deals with ongoing accounting after transition, and a working paper that runs the two together will confuse the next reader. Our guides to reviewing statutory accounts cover the wider change of policy mechanics.

31 December 2026 year end Cumulative catch up (paragraph 1.61(a)) Full retrospective (paragraph 1.61(b))
2025 comparatives Not restated (paragraph 1.62(a)) Restated as if the new Section 23 had always applied
Where the transition effect goes Opening retained earnings at 1 January 2026 Restated balance sheet at 1 January 2025, which is not presented
Contracts in scope Those not completed at 1 January 2026 Those not completed before 1 January 2025, using paragraph 1.65(a)(ii)
Practical expedients available Paragraphs 1.65(b) and (c) Paragraphs 1.65(a) to (d)
Transition disclosure Paragraph 1.63, with 10.13(b) to (d) not required for Section 23 Paragraph 10.13, with 10.13(b) only for the immediately preceding period (paragraph 1.64)

Which contracts does the FRS 102 cumulative catch up reach?

It reaches only contracts that are not completed contracts at the date of initial application (paragraph 1.62(b)). Paragraph 1.67 defines a completed contract by reference to the old rules: one for which the entity has transferred all the goods or services identified under the previous revenue requirements. On our reading, a contract the old policy treated as fully delivered by 31 December 2025 stays outside the adjustment, even if the revised Section 23 would have identified a further performance obligation within it.

A hypothetical example shows how the routes differ in pounds. A client with a 31 December year end has contracts still open at 1 January 2026, and on those contracts the old policy recognised £30,000 more revenue to that date than the revised Section 23 would have done. Of that £30,000, £12,000 relates to 2025 and £18,000 to earlier years.

Hypothetical client, 31 December 2026 year end Cumulative catch up Full retrospective
2025 revenue as presented Unchanged Reduced by £12,000
Opening retained earnings adjusted At 1 January 2026, by £30,000 At 1 January 2025, by £18,000
Retained earnings at 31 December 2025 As originally reported; £30,000 lower from 1 January 2026 Restated, £30,000 lower

For these contracts, both routes leave the same balance at 1 January 2026, before any tax effect. The difference lies in what the reader sees for 2025, and in how much work goes into getting there.

One point is unsettled: paragraph 1.62(c) allows the variable consideration expedient in paragraph 1.65(b) under the catch up route, but 1.65(b) is worded around estimates “in the comparative reporting periods”, which the catch up route does not restate. Factsheet 9 and the ICAEW describe it in terms of contracts completed by the reporting date. If a client relies on it, record the reading the firm has taken.

What must the comparatives and transition note show?

Under the catch up route, the paragraph 1.63 disclosure is narrower than many assume. For the current period only, the entity discloses, to the extent practicable, the amount of the adjustment to revenue and to profit or loss from applying the revised Section 23, with an explanation of the reasons for significant changes. If any of those amounts cannot practicably be determined, it explains why instead. For 2026 accounts, the note therefore compares 2026 as reported with 2026 under the old policy, and says nothing about restating 2025.

Under full restatement, paragraph 1.64 limits the 10.13(b) disclosure to the immediately preceding period.

Company law adds a requirement that transition notes often miss. Schedule 1 paragraph 7 of the Small Companies Regulations, with the same paragraph in the Large and Medium sized Companies Regulations, requires corresponding amounts for every balance sheet and profit and loss item. Where they are not comparable, particulars of the non comparability and of any adjustment must be disclosed in a note. Under the catch up route, 2025 revenue is on the old basis and 2026 is on the new one, so the accounts need that note. Under full restatement the 2025 amounts are adjusted, so the note must give particulars of that adjustment instead.

Lessees have no choice for leases, because paragraph 1.47 says they shall not restate comparative information, so the cumulative effect of the revised Section 20 goes to opening retained earnings, with an equivalent disclosure under paragraph 1.44. If a client restates revenue in full, its 2025 comparatives are restated for revenue but not for leases, and the accounting policies note has to say so plainly.

Small companies, qualifying entities and micro entities

New paragraph 1AC.32B requires Section 1A small companies to give the performance obligation disclosures in paragraphs 23.135(a) to (c): when obligations are typically satisfied, significant payment terms, and the nature of the goods or services, including agent arrangements.

Whether a small company must also give the paragraph 1.63, 1.64 and 1.66 transition disclosures is not stated expressly. Paragraph 1A.17 relieves small entities from the specific disclosures in Section 3 and Sections 8 to 35, but the transition paragraphs sit in Section 1, so this is a judgement for the engagement partner. Where the effect is material, we think a short transition note is the safer course, given the requirement in paragraphs 1A.5 and 1A.16 and the company law note on non comparability, which applies regardless. A UK small entity that adopted early must disclose that fact under paragraph 1.38.

Qualifying entities using the reduced disclosure framework may take the exemptions in paragraph 1.12(cB) from several Section 23 disclosures, including 23.135(a) to (c) and 23.137. The FRC notes that the company law particulars of turnover must still be given.

FRS 105 clients get no choice at all. Paragraph 1.11 of FRS 105 requires the revised Section 18 to be applied prospectively to contracts that begin after the date the amendments are first applied, with no change of policy for contracts in progress. First time adopters of FRS 102 have their own route through paragraph 35.10(y).

How should a partner choose the route for each client?

The ICAEW’s helpsheet says there are no prescribed criteria, and points preparers to the needs and expectations of users with reference to Section 2. In practice, the decision tends to turn on three things.

The first is the users. A lender or prospective buyer who reads trends may want 2025 revenue on the new basis, and full restatement gives them that. The ICAEW also suggests discussing covenant effects with lenders before the first reporting date, which matters more than the choice of route if a ratio moves. The second is the data. Full restatement means rebuilding every contract open during 2025, back to 1 January 2025, and that is hard where the records were kept for the old policy. The third is the size of the effect. The ICAEW rates businesses selling services as higher impact and goods only sellers as lower, so a wholesaler and a software house with the same partner may end up on different routes for good reasons.

Tax should be quantified early. ICAEW commentary says the change of basis rules (CTA 2009 Part 3 Chapter 14, with HMRC guidance from BIM34000) generally bring the net transition amount into account in the first period, which could significantly increase or decrease taxable profits. Lessees, by contrast, spread their adjustments under the Schedule 14 FA 2019 rules, and that spreading does not cover revenue. Higher profits may also bring a company up against the £5 million annual deductions allowance for carried forward losses. We have not seen HMRC guidance specific to the FRS 102 revenue changes, so check the position for each affected client before the computation is filed.

Whatever the route, record the choice and the reasons on the file. Acquirers looking at a practice will want to see a consistent, documented approach across the client book. Our book The Signed Review sets out how we think about evidence of judgement at sign off.

Review points before the accounts are signed

Most of the errors we expect this year are inconsistencies between the chosen route and the rest of the accounts. A reviewer reading every note against the primary statements will find them, but the choice of route stays with the partner who signs. Our statutory accounts review checklist covers the wider file. For revenue transition, check that:

  • comparatives are not restated alongside a reserves adjustment at 1 January 2026, since paragraph 1.62(a) rules that out;
  • the catch up adjustment covers only contracts not completed at the date of initial application, judged under the old rules;
  • the note gives the paragraph 1.63 disclosure, not the full paragraph 10.13 set;
  • under full restatement, the 1 January 2025 balance sheet has been restated in the working papers;
  • any paragraph 1.65 expedient is applied to every contract and its use is disclosed;
  • the policies note explains why revenue comparatives were restated when lease comparatives were not;
  • no FRS 105 client has been given a catch up adjustment;
  • the Schedule 1 paragraph 7 note is present on either route: particulars of the non comparability under the catch up route, or of the adjustment to the 2025 amounts under full restatement;
  • the corporation tax effect of the adjustment has been estimated and discussed with the client.

Key dates

Date What happens
1 January 2025 Start of the earliest period presented under full restatement for a 31 December 2026 year end
1 January 2026 Amendments mandatory for periods beginning on or after this date; date of initial application for a 31 December year end
1 April 2026 Date of initial application for a 31 March year end
31 December 2026 First year end for calendar year clients under the revised Section 23
31 March 2027 First affected year end for 31 March clients

You may also find our article FRS 105 revenue recognition changes for micro entities in 2026 useful.

Questions practices ask

Do I have to restate last year's figures for the new FRS 102 revenue rules?

Not if you take the cumulative catch up route. Paragraph 1.62(a) says an entity using paragraph 1.61(a) shall not restate comparative information, and the cumulative effect goes to opening retained earnings at the date of initial application, which is 1 January 2026 for a 31 December year end. Under full retrospective restatement, the 2025 figures are restated as if the revised Section 23 had always applied.

Is the opening reserves adjustment for revenue taxable in the first year?

ICAEW commentary says the change of basis rules in CTA 2009 Part 3 Chapter 14 generally bring the net transition amount into account in the first period under the amended standard, which could raise or lower taxable profits significantly. The lessee spreading rules do not cover revenue. We have not seen HMRC guidance specific to the revenue changes, so check each client's position.

Can a client adopt the FRS 102 amendments early?

Yes. Early application was permitted, provided all the Periodic Review 2024 amendments are applied at the same time. A company that adopts early must disclose that fact, and in the UK this applies to small entities too. Small entities in the Republic of Ireland are only encouraged to disclose early adoption, and are not required to.

What is the date of initial application for a 31 March year end?

For a company with a 31 March year end that does not adopt early, the first period under the amended FRS 102 ends 31 March 2027, and the date of initial application is 1 April 2026. Under the cumulative catch up route, the adjustment goes to retained earnings at that date and covers contracts not completed by then.

Sources