The incremental borrowing rate for FRS 102 leases is the judgement that moves a lease liability most, and under the amended Section 20 it is also the number a reviewer is least likely to find evidence for on file. This article is for partners and managers who review small company accounts prepared under FRS 102 Section 1A. It sets out what the amended standard allows a lessee to use as a discount rate, the simplification it introduced, how the choice plays out at transition and afterwards, and what we would expect the file to hold. The worked example is hypothetical.
The three rates and the order of choice
Paragraph 20.49 of FRS 102 (September 2024 edition) measures the lease liability at the present value of the lease payments not yet paid. Those payments are discounted at the interest rate implicit in the lease if that rate can be readily determined. If it cannot, the lessee chooses, lease by lease, between its incremental borrowing rate and its obtainable borrowing rate. So the order is the implicit rate first, then a free choice between the other two for each lease.
For most small company lessees of offices, vehicles and equipment, the lessor does not disclose the information needed to derive the implicit rate. The FRC’s factsheet defines the implicit rate as the one that makes the present value of the lease payments and the unguaranteed residual value equal to the fair value of the underlying asset plus the lessor’s initial direct costs, and it expects the lessee to use it if it can be readily determined. When the lessor’s figures are not available, the file should say so, because that statement is what opens the door to the other two rates. Our guide to what the 2026 amendments mean for reviewers covers the surrounding changes to Section 20.
Incremental or obtainable: what each asks for
The Glossary defines the two rates differently:
- The incremental borrowing rate is the rate of interest a lessee would have to pay to borrow over a similar term, and with a similar security, the funds necessary to obtain an asset of a similar value to the right-of-use asset in a similar economic environment.
- The obtainable borrowing rate is the rate of interest a lessee would have to pay to borrow, over a similar term, an amount similar to the total undiscounted value of the lease payments to be included in the measurement of the lease liability.
The first is anchored to the value of the right-of-use asset and to security. The second is anchored to the total of the lease payments, with no reference to the asset’s value or security. The Basis for Conclusions explains why both exist: the obtainable borrowing rate is a simplification, described as broadly similar in concept but expected to be simpler to determine (paragraph B20.12(a)). The simplification is available to any entity applying Section 20. We found no separate rate relief for small entities in Section 20 or in Section 1A. A public benefit entity that cannot readily determine any of the three rates uses the rate on deposits it holds with financial institutions (paragraph PBE20.50), which does not help an ordinary company.
Factsheet 11 sets out an example in which the lessee, unable to determine the implicit rate, chooses the obtainable borrowing rate and takes a bank quote to borrow CU50,000 over a similar term, concluding the rate is 7%. A quote is evidence from outside the company, so a reviewer can inspect it.
At transition, and when the rate changes
At the date of initial application, paragraph 1.51(a) discounts the remaining payments on each former operating lease at the lessee’s incremental borrowing rate or obtainable borrowing rate for that lease at that date. There is no implicit rate step at transition, as the FRC’s lessee factsheet notes in a footnote. Two reliefs bear on the rate. A lessee may apply a single discount rate to a portfolio of leases with reasonably similar characteristics, such as a similar remaining term for a similar class of asset in a similar economic environment (paragraph 1.53(a)). A lessee may instead use the carrying amounts it has calculated under IFRS 16 for group consolidation (paragraph 1.48), in which case the file should hold that group calculation. Our review checklist for FRS 102 Section 1A and FRS 105 accounts shows where lease working sits in a wider review.
After the commencement date the discount rate is generally fixed. The standard lets it change in these situations only:
- A change in the lease term, or in the assessment of a purchase option, requires a revised rate: the implicit rate for the remainder of the term if it can be readily determined, otherwise the incremental or obtainable borrowing rate at the date of reassessment (paragraphs 20.66 and 20.67).
- A change in lease payments caused by an index or rate, or by a residual value guarantee, uses an unchanged rate, unless the change comes from floating interest rates, in which case a revised rate reflecting the change is used (paragraphs 20.68 and 20.69).
- A lease modification that is not a separate lease uses a revised rate under paragraph 20.49 at the effective date, except that an unchanged rate may be used where the extra consideration is insignificant, where scope and consideration both decrease, or where consideration for the remaining term decreases without any reduction in scope (paragraphs 20.71 and 20.72).
So each modification or reassessment on a lease needs a rate, and a reviewer who sees a changed term in the lease schedule should expect a rate with a date beside it.
A hypothetical sensitivity
Every figure here is invented. A lease has three annual payments of £24,000 remaining, paid in arrears, and the implicit rate cannot be readily determined. The table shows the lease liability at each rate the company might defend.
| Rate | Lease liability | Difference from 6% |
|---|---|---|
| 5% | £65,358 | £1,206 higher |
| 6% | £64,152 | Base case |
| 7% | £62,984 | £1,168 lower |
| 8% | £61,850 | £2,302 lower |
A one percentage point change moves this liability by about £1,200 in either direction. On a small lease that is unlikely to matter. On a portfolio of property and vehicle leases the same arithmetic scales with the term and the payments, which is why the choice of rate and the grouping of leases are worth a line in the review notes. The rate also sets the interest charge: at 6% the first year’s interest is £3,849, while at 7% it is £4,409 on a liability of £62,984, so the rate shifts the split between interest and depreciation in the income statement.
What goes on file
FRS 102 does not prescribe documentation for the rate. What follows is what we would expect a manager to look for before the partner signs.
- A statement for each lease or portfolio that the implicit rate could not be readily determined, and why.
- The rate type chosen for each lease. The choice is lease by lease, so the file should show it was made rather than defaulted.
- The evidence: a lender’s quote or recent facility terms, for the right term and an amount that matches the asset (for an incremental borrowing rate) or the total lease payments (for an obtainable borrowing rate).
- The date of the rate, which is the date of initial application at transition and the commencement date for new leases.
- For a portfolio rate, the grouping criteria: remaining term, class of asset, and economic environment.
- The calculation, with the payments, the term and any options considered, so the liability can be recomputed from the file.
- The consistency of the rate with the lease term judgement, since a long assumed term at a short-term borrowing rate is a mismatch.
On disclosure, a lessee not applying Section 1A meets paragraph 20.77(c), which asks for the types of discount rate used and the proportion of the total lease liability calculated using each, and paragraph 20.78, which requires disclosure where the portfolio practical expedient in paragraph 20.13 has been applied. A small entity is not specifically required to give either: Appendix C asks only for additional qualitative and quantitative information where it is needed to understand significant leasing arrangements (paragraph 1AC.31B, with paragraph 20.77 as the similar requirement). A small lessee that mixes rate types or uses a portfolio rate should therefore consider whether to give the proportions or say so. The file for the accounts should let the preparer produce those proportions without rework.
Questions practices ask
Can a company use one rate for every lease?
Only where the leases form a portfolio with similar characteristics. Paragraph 20.13 allows a portfolio approach for a similar lease term on a similar class of asset in a similar economic environment, and an entity not applying Section 1A that uses it discloses that fact (paragraph 20.78). A small entity should consider whether to say so under paragraph 1AC.31B. A single rate for an office and a fleet of vans with different terms would need a reason.
Which of the two rates should a small company choose?
The standard leaves the choice to the lessee, lease by lease (paragraph 20.49). The Basis for Conclusions expects the obtainable borrowing rate to be simpler to determine (paragraph B20.12(a)), so the file should show the evidence for whichever rate is used.
Does a company need a bank quote?
Section 20 does not require one. The FRC’s own example uses a bank quote as the evidence for the rate, so it is the model a reviewer will recognise, but other evidence of what the lessee would have to pay is for the preparer to justify.
Does the rate get reassessed every year?
No. The rate set at commencement is kept unless the lease term or a purchase option assessment changes, a floating rate resets, or a modification occurs (paragraphs 20.66 to 20.72).
Sources
- FRS 102 The Financial Reporting Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland (September 2024 edition), Financial Reporting Council, September 2024
- FRS 102 Factsheet 11: Lease accounting for lessees, FRC staff, November 2024