This article is stated as at 21 November 2026. The FRC updated the text of ISQM (UK) 1 in September 2025 and continues to publish guidance on it, so check the current edition before citing paragraph references. Take advice on your own circumstances before acting.
The ISQM 1 annual evaluation is the conclusion, reached by the partner with ultimate responsibility for quality management, on whether the firm’s system of quality management is doing its job, and it is easy to leave as the thinnest file in the practice. Under ISQM (UK) 1, those with ultimate responsibility and accountability for the firm’s system of quality management must evaluate it at least once a year, as of a point in time the firm chooses, and reach one of three permitted conclusions, documenting the basis for it. Firms that kept the anniversary of the standard’s 15 December 2022 start date will be evaluating as at 15 December 2026.
Who carries out the ISQM 1 annual evaluation?
ISQM (UK) 1, Quality Management for Firms that Perform Audits or Reviews of Financial Statements, or Other Assurance or Related Services Engagements, came into effect on 15 December 2022. The FRC’s current edition was issued in July 2021 and updated in September 2025, and the FRC gave its September 2025 conforming amendments the same effective date of 15 December 2022.
The FRC puts the requirement in one line: “Under ISQM (UK) 1, firms are required to perform an annual evaluation of their system of quality management.” The evaluation is carried out by those with ultimate responsibility and accountability for the system, and ICAEW cites paragraph 53 of the standard for this. In a small audit practice that will often be the sole audit principal. A compliance manager or an external reviewer can gather the information, but the conclusion belongs to the person with ultimate responsibility, and the file should show that they reached it themselves.
The standard is written for firms performing audits, reviews and other assurance or related services engagements under FRC standards. A practice whose work is limited to preparing unaudited accounts should confirm with its professional body how the standard applies to it, although it still needs a working approach to quality on compiled accounts, which our guide to quality management for accounts preparation covers.
Does the evaluation have to be done by 15 December?
The first evaluation was due within a year of the effective date, so by 15 December 2023. After that the requirement is to evaluate at least annually, and ICAEW describes the evaluation as performed “at a specific point in time”. The standard does not fix that point at 15 December. Firms that kept the anniversary will be evaluating as at 15 December 2026, but a firm that chose a different date, such as the end of its compliance year, is not out of step, provided no more than a year passes between evaluations.
ICAEW’s guidance suggests the logical time is the end of the annual compliance cycle, once the detailed audit compliance review that reg 3.20 of the Audit Regulations requires at least annually has been done. The order matters, because an evaluation signed before the compliance review is finished cannot take account of its results, and a conclusion that ignores the firm’s most thorough piece of monitoring is hard to defend. If this year’s review is running late, finish it before your evaluation date and set next year’s timetable so the two fall in the right order.
Which of the three ISQM 1 conclusions applies?
The FRC describes the evaluation in three steps: identify findings from monitoring, identify deficiencies from those findings, then assess each deficiency for severity and pervasiveness. ICAEW points to paragraph 41 of the standard for the assessment of severity and pervasiveness and paragraph 42 for remedial action. Only three conclusions are permitted.
| Conclusion (ISQM (UK) 1, UK firms) | When it fits | What must follow |
|---|---|---|
| The system provides reasonable assurance that its objectives are being achieved | No deficiency found is severe; ICAEW says this will not be appropriate unless the compliance review’s recommendations are minor | Document the basis for the conclusion and update the risk assessment for any changes |
| Except for matters related to identified deficiencies that have a severe but not pervasive effect, the system provides reasonable assurance | One or more severe deficiencies, contained to a part of the system | Prompt and appropriate action, communication of the conclusion and a clear action plan |
| The system does not provide reasonable assurance that its objectives are being achieved | Severe deficiencies with a pervasive effect | Prompt and appropriate action, communication, a clear action plan and a documented understanding of the reasons and the remediation required |
Most of the judgement sits in the middle step. A single cold file review point on one audit may be an isolated finding. The same point on three files reviewed by different managers is more likely a deficiency in the system, perhaps in training, in the firm’s methodology or in how work is allocated, and it has to be assessed for severity before the partner can sign a clean conclusion. If the honest answer is the second conclusion, reach it and write the action plan, because a clean conclusion that the firm’s own file reviews contradict is far harder to defend at a monitoring visit than a qualified one with a plan behind it.
What should the evaluation file contain?
There is no prescribed format for the evaluation or its documentation, and ICAEW’s helpsheet on the annual evaluation says a standard checklist approach is not suitable. The FRC’s Scalability of ISQM (UK) 1 Information Sheet, published on 22 July 2026, adds that “The standard does not define the complexity and formality of the system expected at different firms.” A small practice does not need a large firm’s apparatus, but it does need a record that lets someone else follow how the conclusion was reached.
Drawing on ICAEW’s Audit & Beyond guidance and the FRC’s requirement that the documentation include the basis for the conclusion, a file that stands up would hold the following.
| Item | What it should show |
|---|---|
| Information considered | The risk assessment and how it was updated, progress on last year’s actions, the review of policies and procedures, and monitoring results, including internal and external cold file reviews and any visit from ICAEW’s Quality Assurance Department |
| Findings and deficiencies | Each finding, whether it was judged a deficiency, and the severity and pervasiveness assessment with reasons |
| Root cause analysis | What caused each deficiency, as well as what went wrong on the file |
| Conclusion | Which of the three conclusions was reached, the date it was made as at, and who reached it |
| Basis for the conclusion | A brief justification that links the conclusion to the evidence above |
| Changes and actions | A summary of changes to the risk assessment and the system, and for a qualified or adverse conclusion the action plan and the communication made |
A few pages can do all of this for a small firm, provided the reasoning is written down. A conclusion held in the partner’s head, or reached in a conversation nobody minuted, leaves a reviewer nothing to follow.
Where annual evaluations fall short
The FRC’s September 2025 report, Annual evaluation processes ISQM (UK) 1, lists the weaknesses it found. Its observations come from monitoring the largest firms, but each one applies just as much to a small practice’s evaluation:
- considering a narrow range of information;
- no evidence of how information was reviewed, including reviews done solely through internal discussions without retaining minutes;
- assuming mitigating actions are effective without evidence;
- leadership only receiving reporting when the annual evaluation conclusion is due;
- failure to evidence the basis for leadership’s conclusion.
ICAEW adds two observations of its own. Some firms thought that identifying and assessing quality risks was enough, and some had not dug deep enough when investigating causal factors. ICAEW states that monitoring and remediation, including root cause analysis, are mandatory. In accounts work the same review points tend to recur from year to year, as our note on common errors found at manager review sets out, and a recurring point is usually a sign that last year’s remediation treated the symptom. Before concluding that an action worked, look for evidence on this year’s files that the problem has stopped.
Two habits help. Send monitoring results to the responsible partner as they arrive through the year, so the evaluation is a summing up and not a first reading. And minute the meeting at which the conclusion is reached, recording what was considered and why each deficiency was graded as it was.
Updating the risk assessment for this year’s changes, including AI tools
The evaluation should end with the risk assessment and the system updated for what has changed: new services, departures and new joiners, an acquisition, or new technology, including AI tools used in preparing or reviewing work. A firm that introduced an AI review tool during the year should be able to show where it sits in the risk assessment, what quality risk it creates and how the firm responds to it.
The main response is evidence that people still review the work. A reviewer who accepts a tool’s output without challenge is a quality risk in its own right, and our piece on evidencing human review of AI output looks at how to show on the file that the review took place. Data protection belongs in the same update, since a new tool that processes client data may need a DPIA for an AI review tool before it is used on live files.
Introducing a tool does not move responsibility: the partner who signs the accounts or the audit report still owns the judgement, a point our guide to professional responsibility for AI-reviewed accounts covers in more depth. Acquirers looking at a practice will want to see recent evaluations in due diligence, because they show more plainly than any policy manual whether the firm’s quality management works in practice.
Key dates
| Date | What happens (ISQM (UK) 1, UK firms) |
|---|---|
| 15 December 2022 | ISQM (UK) 1 and ISQM (UK) 2 came into effect |
| 15 December 2023 | First annual evaluation due, within one year of the effective date |
| 8 September 2025 | FRC published its report on annual evaluation processes |
| 25 September 2025 | FRC published the updated edition of ISQM (UK) 1, with conforming amendments effective from 15 December 2022 |
| 22 July 2026 | FRC published the Scalability of ISQM (UK) 1 Information Sheet |
| 15 December 2026 | Next evaluation for firms that set their evaluation date on the anniversary of the effective date (a firm choice, not a statutory deadline) |
Whatever date your firm uses, set this year’s evaluation to fall after the audit compliance review is complete, so that its results feed into the conclusion.
Questions practices ask
Can our annual audit compliance review double as the ISQM 1 evaluation?
Not on its own. The compliance review required at least annually under reg 3.20 of the Audit Regulations is one of the most important inputs, and ICAEW suggests carrying out the evaluation once it is complete. The evaluation itself is a separate conclusion by the person with ultimate responsibility, drawing on all monitoring, root cause analysis and the updated risk assessment, with its own documented basis.
Will QAD treat an 'except for' conclusion as a failure?
ICAEW's Quality Assurance Department has said that reaching the second or third conclusion should not be treated as a failure in itself, and that the second is expected to arise periodically at larger firms. A reviewer will look for a well supported assessment of the deficiencies, prompt action, a clear action plan and evidence that the conclusion was communicated.
Does the FRC decide whether our ISQM 1 conclusion was right?
The FRC monitors the largest twelve audit firms' compliance with ISQM (UK) 1 and ISQM (UK) 2, and says it does not reperform the annual evaluation to form a view on what the conclusion should be. Its attention is on the process: the range of information considered, how it was reviewed and whether the basis for leadership's conclusion is evidenced.
Do we need to tell staff the outcome of the ISQM 1 evaluation?
Where the conclusion is the second or third, the firm must communicate it as well as taking prompt and appropriate action. For a clean conclusion, sharing the result and any changes to policies with the audit team is sensible, because the people doing the work are the ones who make the changes stick from one year to the next.
Sources
- Annual evaluation processes ISQM (UK) 1
- Scalability of ISQM (UK) 1 Information Sheet
- Systems of Quality Management Monitoring
- ISQM (UK) 1
- FRC publishes conforming amendments to International Standards on Auditing
- ISQM (UK) 1 Annual evaluation
- Enhancing your firm's annual SoQM evaluation
- Learning from annual SoQM appraisals
- ISQM1: early findings from quality assurance monitoring
- ISQM 1 monitoring and remediation
- One year on from ISQM 1