§ Going concern, related parties, directors’ loans and dividends: the judgement areas in small company accounts

Going concern, related parties, directors’ loans and dividends: the judgement areas in small company accounts

Guides

Small company accounts disclosures on going concern, related parties, directors’ loans, dividends, events after the reporting date and provisions are where review takes the most judgement. This guide is for partners and managers in UK chartered practices who review accounts under FRS 102 Section 1A or FRS 105 at the standard of an experienced audit manager. It expands the summary in our review checklist for FRS 102, Section 1A and FRS 105 accounts, and gives the paragraph or section behind each point.

Going concern

The assessment period

FRS 102 paragraph 3.8 requires management to assess whether the entity is a going concern, taking into account all available information about the future, which is at least, but is not limited to, 12 months from the date the financial statements are authorised for issue. FRS 105 paragraph 3.3 uses the same period for micro-entities. Because the period runs from approval, check the forecast dates against the date on the balance sheet.

What the note must say from 2026

For periods beginning on or after 1 January 2026 (paragraph 1.37(b)), paragraph 1AC.2C requires a small entity to give the disclosures in paragraphs 3.8A and 3.9. Where the going concern basis is used, 3.8A asks for that fact, confirmation that management has considered information about the future as set out in paragraph 3.8, and any significant judgements made in the assessment. Paragraph 3.9 requires disclosure of material uncertainties that may cast significant doubt on the entity’s ability to continue. If the going concern basis is not used, the entity discloses that fact, the basis used instead and the reason.

Example note wording (illustrative only)

Our wording, not the FRC’s; adapt it to the facts.

Illustrative, no material uncertainty: “The financial statements have been prepared on a going concern basis. The directors have considered information about the future covering at least 12 months from the date these financial statements were approved, including cash flow forecasts and the company’s bank facilities. The significant judgement was whether the overdraft facility due for renewal in [month and year] will be renewed on similar terms.”

Illustrative, material uncertainty: “The company made a loss in the year and the bank has not yet confirmed renewal of its overdraft facility, due in [month and year]. These conditions indicate a material uncertainty that may cast significant doubt on the company’s ability to continue as a going concern. The directors expect the facility to be renewed and have prepared the financial statements on a going concern basis.”

Review points

  • A note that states the basis and nothing more falls short of 3.8A for a 2026 period. Look for the confirmation and the judgements.
  • After the year end, a decision to liquidate or cease trading rules out the going concern basis (32.7A), and a deterioration may mean the assumption needs reconsidering (32.7B).
  • FRS 105 paragraph 6.2 lists the micro-entity notes: off-balance sheet arrangements, employee numbers, directors’ advances and guarantees, and financial commitments. The paragraph 3.3 assessment is still required, so the file should show it.

Who counts

Under paragraph 33.2(a), a person or a close member of that person’s family is related to the reporting entity if the person has control, joint control or significant influence over it, or is one of its key management personnel, which paragraph 33.6 says includes any director. The glossary’s close members of the family include the person’s children and spouse or domestic partner.

Directors’ other businesses need the most digging. An entity is related if it is controlled or jointly controlled by a person identified in 33.2(a) (33.2(b)(vi)), or if a person who controls the reporting entity has significant influence over it or is one of its key management personnel (33.2(b)(vii)). A company controlled by the director or the director’s spouse that bills the company for rent or management services is therefore related. Paragraph 33.4(a) is the counterweight: two entities are not related simply because they share a director. The reviewer needs the shareholdings as well as the directorships, and should search the ledgers for each name.

What Section 1A now requires

Paragraph 1AC.35 requires a small entity to give the disclosures in paragraphs 33.9 and 33.14, subject to paragraphs 33.1A and 33.11. The basis for conclusions (B1A.10) says that for UK small entities, following the Periodic Review 2024 amendments, disclosure is now required of all related party transactions, subject to the exemptions open to all entities. Paragraph A3.11F confirms that this also meets the company law requirement on transactions not concluded under normal market conditions.

Paragraph 33.9 asks for the nature of the relationship and, at a minimum, the amount of the transactions, outstanding balances and commitments with their terms and any guarantees, provisions for uncollectible receivables, and the bad or doubtful debt expense. Paragraph 33.1A exempts transactions between group members provided any subsidiary that is a party is wholly owned, so a partly owned subsidiary’s dealings with its parent are still disclosed.

What reviewers miss

  • Transactions with no price still count, because paragraph 33.8 applies regardless of whether a price is charged, so rent-free use of a director’s property counts.
  • A director’s personal guarantee of the company’s bank debt is a guarantee received by the company, so paragraph 33.9(b)(ii) asks for the details of guarantees given or received, and 33.12(h) lists the provision of guarantees among the transactions to disclose.
  • Paragraph 33.13 forbids saying transactions were on arm’s length terms unless that can be substantiated.

Directors’ loans and section 455

Disclosure under section 413

Section 413 requires the notes to give details of advances and credits granted to directors and guarantees entered into on their behalf: for each advance, its amount, an indication of the interest rate, its main conditions, and any amounts repaid, written off or waived, with totals (s413(3) and (5)). Paragraph 1AC.36 carries this into Section 1A and FRS 105 paragraph 6.2(c) into micro-entity accounts. Section 413(6) covers anyone who was a director at any time in the year, and s413(7) applies to every advance subsisting at any time in the year, whenever made. The section sets no minimum, so a balance cleared before the year end still belongs in the note. Read the whole loan account for the year as well as the closing balance.

Members’ approval

Under s197(1), a company may not make a loan to a director of the company or its holding company, or guarantee or secure a loan made to one, unless the members have approved it by resolution. Members must first receive a memorandum setting out, among other things, the amount and purpose of the loan (s197(3) and (4)). No approval is needed from the members of a wholly-owned subsidiary (s197(5)(b)). Section 207(1) removes the need for approval where the loan and other relevant transactions do not exceed £10,000, and s204 does so for funds to meet expenditure on company business up to an aggregate of £50,000. Sections 198 and 201 (quasi-loans and credit transactions) bind only public companies and their associates. Checked against legislation.gov.uk (Companies Act 2006 sections 204 and 207) on 21 November 2026.

A loan made without approval is voidable at the company’s instance, and the persons listed in s213(4), who include the director, must account for any gain and indemnify the company for any loss (s213(3)). Under s214 it can no longer be avoided if the members affirm it within a reasonable period. For an overdrawn account above £10,000, ask to see the resolution or the affirmation.

The section 455 charge and the repayment window

Where a close company lends to a participator or an associate, s455 of the Corporation Tax Act 2010 charges the company tax at the dividend upper rate in section 8(2) of the Income Tax Act 2007 for the tax year in which the loan is made. HMRC’s Company Taxation Manual gives 33.75% for loans made on or after 6 April 2022 and 35.75% from 6 April 2026, matching section 8(2). A period spanning 6 April 2026 can carry both rates, so build the tax note advance by advance. Checked against legislation.gov.uk (Income Tax Act 2007 section 8) and HMRC’s Company Taxation Manual (CTM61505) on 21 November 2026.

  • The tax is due on the day after the end of nine months from the end of the accounting period in which the loan was made (s455(3)).
  • Relief is given when the loan is repaid, released or written off, on a claim within four years from the end of the financial year in which that happens (s458(2) and (3)). HMRC’s manual (CTM61610) says no tax need be paid if the loan is repaid, released or written off before the tax falls due.
  • If repayment comes after the due date, relief cannot be given until nine months after the end of the accounting period of repayment (s458(5)).

Bed and breakfasting: now section 464ZA

Older checklists cite section 464C. Finance Act 2025 section 81 omitted Chapter 3B of Part 10 of CTA 2010, which held it, and inserted sections 464ZA and 464ZB, treated as in force from 30 October 2024.

  • The 30 day rule (s464ZA(1)): where repayments of £5,000 or more are made within a 30 day period in which new loans of £5,000 or more are made to the same person or an associate in a later accounting period, the repayment is matched to the new loans, leaving the original loan outstanding.
  • The arrangements rule (s464ZA(3)): where £15,000 or more is owed immediately before a repayment and arrangements had been made for new loans of £5,000 or more to replace it, the repayment is matched to those new loans.
  • Neither rule applies to a repayment that itself gives rise to an income tax charge on the participator or associate (s464ZA(6)).

Checked against legislation.gov.uk (Corporation Tax Act 2010 section 464ZA) on 21 November 2026.

HMRC’s manual (CTM61615) tells officers to obtain a breakdown of the loan account and bank statements, and to check that transactions happened in the right order and on the right dates. A reviewer can run the same test before the accounts are signed: trace the year end repayment to the bank, then look at the 30 days after it.

Dividends and distributable reserves

The legal tests

A company may only make a distribution out of profits available for the purpose: its accumulated, realised profits, so far as not already distributed or capitalised, less its accumulated, realised losses, so far as not written off in a capital reduction or reorganisation (s830(1) and (2)). Lawfulness is judged by reference to the profits, losses, assets, liabilities, provisions, share capital and reserves in the relevant accounts (s836(1)). These are the last annual accounts, meaning those last circulated to members under section 423 (s837(1)), unless interim accounts are needed because the annual accounts do not support the distribution, or initial accounts are used in the first accounting reference period (s836(2)).

For a private company, interim accounts must enable a reasonable judgement of those items (s838(1)); the further requirements in s838(3) to (6), including signature and filing, apply to public companies. If an applicable requirement is not met, the accounts cannot be relied on and the distribution is treated as contravening the rules (s836(4)). A member who knows, or has reasonable grounds for believing, that a distribution was unlawful is liable to repay it (s847(2)). The ICAEW’s helpsheet on illegal dividends adds that losses since the relevant accounts must be considered, as must the company’s ability to meet its debts as they fall due.

How a reviewer checks reserves before a dividend

  1. Identify the relevant accounts for each dividend paid in the year and since the year end.
  2. Take the profit and loss reserve from those accounts, removing anything that is not realised (s830(2)). The ICAEW helpsheet points to its TECH 02/17 BL guidance on realised and distributable profits.
  3. Deduct dividends already paid against the same accounts.
  4. Where the annual accounts fall short, look for interim accounts that support the dividend and were in front of the board when it was declared.
  5. Check the board minute and dividend voucher. The ICAEW says the paperwork should be current and not created at a later date.

When the check fails

The ICAEW helpsheet says that where profits fall later in the year after interim dividends were properly substantiated, the liability to repay would not normally arise. Where a dividend was not supported by relevant accounts and reserves are now in deficit, it suggests full disclosure in the notes, saying either that the dividend is liable to be repaid or that shareholders received it unknowingly, which director shareholders cannot say. It also says that without proper paperwork a payment to a shareholder would be treated as a loan and shown as a debtor. For a director shareholder that brings in the s413 note and, in a close company, section 455, so review the dividend and the loan account together.

Paragraph 1AC.40 requires disclosure of dividends declared and paid or payable during the period. A dividend declared after the reporting date is not a liability at that date (paragraph 32.8).

Events after the reporting date

Section 32 covers events between the end of the reporting period and the date the accounts are authorised for issue (32.2 and 32.3). Adjusting events give evidence of conditions at the year end and are reflected in the figures (32.4). Paragraph 32.5 gives examples, including a court case settled after the year end that confirms an obligation, a customer’s bankruptcy that usually confirms a loss on a receivable, and the discovery of fraud or errors. Non-adjusting events reflect later conditions and are not adjusted for (32.6).

For a small entity, 1AC.39 requires the nature and financial effect of material events after the reporting date that are not reflected in the income statement or balance sheet. Paragraph 32.10 allows a statement that an estimate cannot be made, and 32.11 gives examples such as a major disposal, a restructuring and significant new guarantees. In review, ask what has happened since the year end and record the answer close to the approval date.

Provisions and contingencies

Paragraph 21.4 allows a provision only where there is an obligation at the reporting date from a past event, a transfer of economic benefits is probable (more likely than not), and the amount can be estimated reliably. A contingent liability is a possible obligation, or a present one failing the probability or measurement test, and is disclosed unless an outflow is remote; where the entity is jointly and severally liable, the part expected to be met by others is a contingent liability (21.12).

Paragraph 1AC.31C requires a small entity to give the disclosures in paragraphs 21.14 to 21.17A:

  • for each class of provision, a reconciliation of the movements, a brief description of the obligation and expected timing, the uncertainties and any expected reimbursement (21.14), with no comparatives required;
  • for each class of contingent liability not judged remote, a description and, when practicable, its financial effect, uncertainties and any reimbursement (21.15);
  • for a probable contingent asset, its nature and, when practicable, its financial effect (21.16); and
  • the nature and business purpose of financial guarantee contracts issued (21.17A).

Paragraph 21.17 allows reduced disclosure in extremely rare cases of serious prejudice in a dispute, but the fact and the reason must still be given. In review, ask for facility letters to find cross-guarantees of group borrowing, and trace dilapidations, onerous contracts and claims in board minutes or solicitors’ letters to a provision, a contingent liability note or a recorded conclusion that the outflow is remote.

What the file should show

We would expect the file to hold forecasts covering at least 12 months from approval, a list of directors’ and family interests searched against the ledgers, the full loan account with any resolution and the s455 working, a reserves check for each dividend, the post year end enquiries, and the documents behind the provisions note.

Our guide to building review evidence into quality management covers this, and The Signed Review sets out the principle that no partner should be asked to sign a figure that cannot be traced back to its source. Our notes on what the 2026 amendments change for reviewers cover the rest of the Periodic Review 2024. We built Infinite Accountant as an AI review of statutory accounts at the standard of an experienced audit manager, for UK chartered practices; the conclusions remain the partner’s, as our guide on who stays responsible when AI is used in review explains.

Further reading

Questions practices ask

Does a Section 1A company now need a full going concern note?

For periods beginning on or after 1 January 2026, yes. Paragraph 1AC.2C brings in paragraphs 3.8A and 3.9: the basis, confirmation that management considered information about the future as set out in paragraph 3.8, any significant judgements, and any material uncertainties.

Does a director’s loan repaid before the year end still need disclosing?

Yes, because section 413(7) applies to every advance subsisting at any time in the financial year.

What is the section 455 rate on a loan made in 2026?

For a loan made on or after 6 April 2026, 35.75%, the dividend upper rate for that tax year; 33.75% applies to loans made from 6 April 2022 up to then. Checked against legislation.gov.uk and HMRC’s Company Taxation Manual (CTM61505) on 21 November 2026.

Is section 464C still the bed and breakfasting rule?

No, because Finance Act 2025 section 81 replaced it with section 464ZA, treated as in force from 30 October 2024, which holds the 30 day rule and the arrangements rule.

Must a small company now disclose every related party transaction?

For UK small entities applying the Periodic Review 2024 amendments, the FRC’s basis for conclusions says disclosure is now required of all related party transactions, subject to the exemptions open to all entities, such as dealings within a group where any subsidiary party is wholly owned (paragraph 33.1A).

Sources