An unlawful dividend is a distribution made in contravention of Part 23 of the Companies Act 2006, and a reviewer can often see the signs in a set of accounts before anyone asks the question. This article is for partners and managers in chartered practices who review small company accounts. It covers how a dividend comes to be unlawful under sections 830 and 836, what the accounts should show about dividends, how a reviewer spots a problem, and what section 847 says about the consequences.
What makes a dividend unlawful
Section 829(1) defines a distribution as every description of distribution of a company’s assets to its members, whether in cash or otherwise, subject to a short list of exceptions in section 829(2). A dividend is the usual example. Section 830(1) allows a company to make a distribution only out of profits available for the purpose, and section 830(2) defines those profits as its accumulated, realised profits, so far as not previously used by distribution or capitalisation, less its accumulated, realised losses, so far as not previously written off in a duly made reduction or reorganisation of capital.
Whether a particular distribution meets that test is decided by reference to the relevant accounts (s836(1)). Our guide to going concern, related parties, directors’ loans and dividends sets out why dividends belong among the judgement areas of a review. If the relevant accounts cannot be relied on, the distribution is treated as contravening Part 23 (s836(4)). That is how a dividend becomes unlawful even when the company had the cash.
How unlawful dividends arise
The sections above point to a handful of routes. Each is a gap between what the directors paid and what the relevant accounts supported.
- The reserves were not there, because the dividend exceeded the realised profits available under section 830(2), measured on the relevant accounts.
- Unrealised profits were counted, although section 830(2) refers to realised profits only, so a revaluation gain or similar item cannot support a dividend simply because it sits in reserves.
- Earlier distributions were forgotten, yet profits count only so far as not previously used by distribution (s830(2)), so a second dividend in the year draws on what the first left behind.
- The last annual accounts did not qualify, because they must be the accounts last circulated to members, properly prepared, and audited unless the company is exempt and the directors take the exemption (s837(1) to (3)). A set that fails these requirements may not be relied on (s836(4)).
- Interim accounts were used without meeting the standard, which is that they must enable a reasonable judgment on the items in section 836(1) (s838(1)), with further requirements for a public company (s838(2) to (6)).
- No relevant accounts were looked at, and the dividend was declared by habit, from the bank balance or the director’s wish, with nothing on file to test it against.
Our statutory accounts review checklist includes dividends with nothing on file to show the relevant accounts supported them as a common manager review point.
What the accounts should show
The accounting standard asks for a modest amount on dividends, and it sits in a few places.
- A small entity applying Section 1A of FRS 102 must disclose dividends declared and paid or payable during the period (paragraph 1AC.40). An entity that presents a statement of income and retained earnings shows the same item in it (paragraph 6.5(b)).
- If an entity declares a dividend after the end of the reporting period, it must not recognise a liability at that date, because no obligation exists then (paragraph 32.8). The amount may be shown as a segregated component of retained earnings.
- The nature and financial effect of material events after the reporting date that the statements do not reflect must be stated (paragraph 1AC.39). A material dividend declared after the year end is a candidate.
None of these paragraphs asks the accounts to demonstrate that the dividend was lawful, so that evidence lives on the file and the reviewer has to ask for it.
How a reviewer spots one
A positive balance on the profit and loss reserve at the year end does not settle the question, because section 836(1) looks to the relevant accounts and not to the closing position of the year in which the dividend was paid.
The figures below are hypothetical. A company’s last annual accounts, circulated to members, show a profit and loss reserve of £30,000 made up of realised profits. No other distribution has been made since those accounts. The directors declare a dividend of £45,000 in the following March and prepare no interim accounts. The company earns a profit of £20,000 in that year, so the closing reserve in the new accounts is £5,000 and reads as healthy.
| Item | £ |
|---|---|
| Reserve per last annual accounts | 30,000 |
| Dividend declared | 45,000 |
| Excess over the relevant accounts | 15,000 |
| Closing reserve after profit of £20,000 for the year | 5,000 |
On those facts the dividend exceeded the profits shown in the last annual accounts by £15,000, and no interim accounts existed to justify it under section 836(2)(a). The closing reserve hides this, because later profit arrived after the dividend was declared.
Questions we would put on a review:
- What are the dividends in the period, with dates, and where is the board minute or declaration for each?
- Which accounts were the relevant accounts on each date, and do the reserves in them cover the dividend after earlier distributions?
- Do the reserves include revaluation gains or other items that may be unrealised?
- If interim accounts were used, are they on file, signed and dated, and do they enable a reasonable judgment on the section 836(1) items?
- Does the dividend disclosure agree to the statement of income and retained earnings and to the movement on reserves?
- Has anything after the year end changed the position, such as a dividend declared after the reporting date, which paragraph 32.8 keeps out of liabilities and paragraph 1AC.39 may require to be disclosed?
What section 847 says
We limit this section to the text of the Act. Section 847 applies where a distribution, or part of one, made to a member is made in contravention of Part 23. If at the time of the distribution the member knows or has reasonable grounds for believing that it is so made, the member is liable to repay it, or its relevant part, to the company. For a distribution not made in cash the member instead pays a sum equal to its value at that time (s847(2)).
Section 847(3) says this is without prejudice to any obligation outside the section for a member to repay a distribution unlawfully made. Section 847(4) excludes financial assistance in contravention of sections 678 or 679 and payments for the redemption or purchase of a company’s own shares.
Whether a particular member knew, and what else follows for the company and its directors, depends on facts and law outside the sections we have set out. A review point should be recorded and cleared before the board approves the accounts, and the partner decides what advice to give.
Questions practices ask
Can a company with cash in the bank still pay an unlawful dividend?
Yes. Section 830(1) tests the distribution against profits available for the purpose, not against cash. The relevant accounts supply those figures (s836(1)).
Do unrealised profits count towards a dividend?
Section 830(2) defines profits available for distribution as accumulated, realised profits less accumulated, realised losses, so unrealised profits are not within the definition.
Must a dividend declared after the year end be shown as a liability?
No. Paragraph 32.8 of FRS 102 says an entity that declares a dividend after the reporting period must not recognise it as a liability at the end of that period. Paragraph 1AC.39 and paragraph 1AC.40 may still call for disclosure.
Who repays an unlawful dividend?
Under section 847(2), a member who knew, or had reasonable grounds for believing, that the distribution was made in contravention of Part 23 is liable to repay it to the company. Section 847(3) leaves other obligations to repay untouched.
Does a small company need to show anything more than the dividend figure?
Section 1A requires disclosure of dividends declared and paid or payable (paragraph 1AC.40). Whether the dividend was lawful is not a disclosure item, so the evidence belongs on the review file.
Sources
- Companies Act 2006, section 829: meaning of “distribution”, legislation.gov.uk, read 21 November 2026
- Companies Act 2006, section 830: distributions to be made only out of profits available, legislation.gov.uk, read 21 November 2026
- Companies Act 2006, section 836: justification of distribution by reference to relevant accounts, legislation.gov.uk, read 21 November 2026
- Companies Act 2006, section 837: requirements where last annual accounts used, legislation.gov.uk, read 21 November 2026
- Companies Act 2006, section 838: requirements where interim accounts used, legislation.gov.uk, read 21 November 2026
- Companies Act 2006, section 847: consequences of unlawful distribution, legislation.gov.uk, read 21 November 2026
- FRS 102 The Financial Reporting Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland (September 2024 edition), Financial Reporting Council, September 2024