§ InsightsNo. 083

Cold file review or hot review for accounts preparation

What a hot review and a cold file review each catch on accounts preparation work, how a small practice can choose, and what to record.

A reviewer and a preparer going through a file together, comparing cold file review with hot review

A cold file review or a hot review for accounts preparation work answers two different questions: can this set of accounts still be put right, and are the firm’s procedures producing good files? This article is for partners and compliance principals in practices that prepare accounts without auditing them, and it sets out what each review catches, how a small practice can choose between them, and what to write down so the choice can be shown to someone else.

What each review catches

A hot review takes place before the accounts are finalised. Its value is that anything it finds can be corrected in the accounts in hand: a note that no longer agrees to the ledger, a comparative that was not rolled forward, a disclosure the client’s circumstances have outgrown. The reviewer is looking at one set of accounts and the evidence behind it.

A cold review takes place after the file is complete. It cannot change the accounts that went out, so it earns its place differently. It shows whether the firm’s own procedures were followed, whether the work can be followed by someone who was not there, and whether the same slip keeps appearing across clients. A single missed disclosure is a hot review point. The same missed disclosure on several files is a cold review finding about a template or a training gap.

Neither replaces the other. Our guide to quality management for accounts preparation sets both inside the wider picture of engagement letters, compilation reports and evidence of review, and this article goes deeper on the choice between them.

What ICAEW says about each

ICAEW’s Practice Assurance guidance for sole practitioners and smaller firms (Standard 4, published 1 May 2018) says that all firms, other than sole practitioners with no staff, should have procedures to supervise and review work, and that it is usual for senior staff to review the work of more junior staff. On how much to review hot, one of its top tips is direct: if you have competent staff you do not necessarily need to review everything that goes out the door, so formulate a review policy on a risk basis and, for the work you do not review hot, review a sample cold from time to time.

The same guidance asks firms to have a policy for the review of files, including hot reviews, and to keep evidence of any review on file. It also suggests that firms review some of their files cold to see whether they can follow all the work that has been done.

ICAEW’s separate guidance for larger firms lists, as best practice, cold file reviews on non-audit assignments, and suggests that they include consideration of the adequacy of recording work. It also lists documenting reviews so it is clear what has been reviewed and who reviewed it, and preparing action plans for the issues found and monitoring the progress of those plans. Accounts preparation is non-audit work, so that best practice is a sensible benchmark for your files whatever your size, though it is written for larger firms.

The smaller-firm guidance lists, as best practice, whole-firm and cold file reviews each year, with periodic external reviews considered, cold file review results given to all principals and staff with a note of any required remedial action, and that action followed up. ICAEW’s compliance review helpsheet, updated on 8 October 2025, states that the Practice Assurance Regulations and Standards do not require a compliance review. If your practice does one, it is a choice you make and a record you will want to be able to show.

Choosing for a small practice

A practical way to choose is to start from who prepared the file and how risky it is, then decide the review rather than defaulting to the same one for every client.

  • A newly qualified or newly joined preparer: review hot, because the accounts can still be corrected and the reviewer learns what the preparer finds hard.
  • A client with a judgement area, such as going concern, a director’s loan that crosses the year end, or a related party arrangement: review hot, with the partner involved. Our guide to the judgement areas in small company accounts lists the points worth testing.
  • An experienced preparer on a stable, repeat client: ICAEW accepts that not everything needs a hot review, so these files can sit in the cold sample.
  • A sole practitioner with no staff: ICAEW says a review still applies. For a particularly complex engagement, it suggests a hot review from a third party, such as an external consultant with expertise in the area, and for compliance reviews it suggests reciprocal reviews with someone in a similar situation.

The cold sample should lean towards higher risk work. ICAEW’s smaller-firm guidance says the compliance review sample should be selected primarily to focus on higher risk assignments, while all professional staff and all types of work are covered over a period of time. ICAEW’s larger-firm guidance adds that reviewers need to be sufficiently independent so that they do not review their own work or that of their close colleagues, so a two-partner practice might swap files at the year end rather than let each partner review their own.

A worked example

This example is hypothetical. A practice prepares the accounts of a small trading company with a director’s loan. The preparer’s draft shows a loan from the director of £14,800 in the balance sheet and in the related party note. The hot reviewer agrees the note to the ledger and finds the ledger balance is £18,400, after a £3,600 payment the director made in the last month of the year was posted to a suspense account.

The hot review fixes the accounts: the payment is reallocated, the balance sheet and note agree, and the review record shows the point, the correction and who cleared it. Nothing about this client’s accounts is left to the cold review.

Later in the year the cold reviewer, who worked on neither file, samples a different client and finds an unexplained suspense balance at the year end. Taken with the hot review point, the practice has two files with the same cause. The cold review finding is about the practice: the year end checklist has no step clearing suspense accounts before the draft is issued. The remedial action is to add the step, then check on later files that it was used.

How to document the choice

ICAEW’s guidance lists, as essentials, a policy for the review of files and evidence of any review kept on file, and says that where review papers are not retained (for example after an external consultant’s review), a note should be made on file that a review has taken place. We would record four things, which together let you show that the choice was deliberate.

  1. The policy: which work is reviewed hot, which is sampled cold, and the reason, such as the preparer’s experience or the client’s risk.
  2. For a hot review: what was reviewed, which version of the draft, who reviewed it, the points raised, how each was cleared and the date.
  3. For a cold review: why the file was selected, who reviewed it, that they had no part in the work, the findings, and whether the recorded work let them follow what was done.
  4. For findings: an action plan, an owner, and a later check that the action worked.

The review itself needs a standard to test against. Our review checklist for FRS 102, Section 1A and FRS 105 accounts gives the points a reviewer works through. Whichever review you run, the partner who signs is still responsible for the accounts. Our note on signing off AI-reviewed accounts explains why that holds when a tool does part of a hot review.

Questions practices ask

Do we have to review every set of accounts before they go out?

ICAEW’s guidance for smaller firms says that if you have competent staff you do not necessarily need to review everything hot. For the work you do not review hot, its top tip is to review a sample cold from time to time, and its essentials list a policy for the review of files, including hot reviews, and evidence of any review kept on file.

Is a cold review a Practice Assurance requirement?

ICAEW lists regular cold file reviews as best practice, and says the Practice Assurance Regulations and Standards do not require a formal compliance review. Firms that do one can use ICAEW’s helpsheet and checklist. Separately, ICAEW’s Standard 4 essentials do list a policy for the review of files and evidence of any review kept on file.

Can the preparer carry out the cold review of their own file?

ICAEW’s guidance for larger firms says reviewers need to be sufficiently independent that they do not review their own work or that of their close colleagues. In a small team, swap files between partners or use an external reviewer.

What should a sole practitioner do?

ICAEW says a sole practitioner must not think that review does not apply to them. It suggests a third-party hot review for a particularly complex engagement, reciprocal compliance reviews with someone in a similar situation, and a note on file that a review took place where review papers are not retained.

Sources